Files
wordcraft/docs/localization-parity.md
T
2e9d4a22ce Chinese interface: keep a system CJK fallback after the bundled face; find PingFang on macOS 12 (#486) (#495)
The screenshots in #486 show exactly the characters BIZ UDPGothic (the
Japanese interface face) lacks: 选项规语简户另为导 … in Simplified and
啟內另 … in Traditional, with "?" in the Inter-based medium/semibold
families (no U+25FB replacement glyph) and boxes in the proportional one.
That is the font chain of v0.4.0 and earlier, which embedded no Chinese
face and had no installed-font fallback; v0.5.0 (#248) embeds Noto Sans
CJK SC. This hardens the chain so it can't silently regress:

- The installed CJK font is chosen by coverage: it is added after the
  embedded faces whenever they leave a CJK character of the CJK catalogs
  or the language names without a glyph (not only when no "Hans" face
  exists), and the face picked is the one mapping the most of those
  characters.
- macOS: look inside com_apple_MobileAsset_Font<N>/<hash>.asset/AssetData
  (bounded, one level) where macOS 10.15+ keeps PingFang.ttc, also under
  /System/Library/Assets; PingFangUI.ttc as a last resort.
- Test: every CJK character of the zh-hans, zh-hant and ja catalogs and
  the language names has a glyph in the embedded chain in all three
  interface weights (skips without craft-fonts; fails with a Japanese-only
  craft-fonts, listing exactly the characters from the screenshots).

Co-authored-by: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Co-authored-by: Brandon Thomas <echelon@gmail.com>
2026-10-11 17:26:23 -04:00

6.8 KiB
Raw Blame History

Localization parity with Microsoft Word

Last reviewed: 2026-10-10 · Last updated: 2026-10-11 · Change: minor (CJK interface font coverage, #486; previously minor: Turkish interface added; previously major: first version; catalogs measured from crates/ui-egui/src/i18n, Word's languages from its bundle listing) · Target: Microsoft Word (Microsoft 365) for Mac 16.113.4

Interface languages, script support and proofing per language. How translation works (catalog format, adding a language, clean-room rule): crates/ui-egui/src/i18n/mod.rs.

Dimension: ~25% (estimated), 80–130 h to full for the twelve key languages plus ~50 h for the other ~18 languages Word ships, plus native-speaker review (human).

What Word ships (measured by listing the bundle)

  • 30 interface languages (31 .lproj folders incl. Base): ar, cs, da, de, el, en, en-GB, es, es-MX, fi, fr, fr-CA, he, hu, id, it, ja, ko, nl, no, pl, pt (BR), pt-PT, ru, sk, sv, th, tr, zh-CN, zh-TW. Arabic and Hebrew get a mirrored interface. No Hindi or Vietnamese interface on Mac.
  • 120 proofing tools (SharedSupport/Proofing Tools): spellers for ~50 languages, grammar checkers for ~20, hyphenators for ~16, thesauri for ~20.

What WordCraft ships (measured)

  • 12 interface languages: English plus zh-hans, zh-hant, ja, uk, es, pt-br, Serbian sr/sr-latn (#250), Estonian et, Turkish tr and Russian ru. Catalogs have 1,305–1,450 entries each. A test (every_tab_and_command_is_translated) enforces that every ribbon tab, command label and ribbon location is translated in every language.
  • Of the 675 English strings a scan extracts from tl!(…) calls and command labels/locations, each catalog covers 661 (98%). Some newer dialog and pane strings (Equation tab tooltips, Zotero, Read Aloud, Backstage greetings) aren't wrapped in tl! yet, so they show in English in every language: the true share of visible strings is ~93–95% (estimated).
  • Pending PRs: German (#203), Norwegian Bokmål (#208) and Nynorsk (#210), Hebrew with RTL (#20).
  • Proofing: English only (one dictionary, rule-based grammar, English hyphenation patterns).
  • Document scripts: shaping via HarfRust (HarfBuzz port) for every script; bidi (UAX #9) and Arabic shaping tested (#207); IME on all desktop platforms (winit fixes pending, #155–#164).

The twelve key languages

Status: full = every user-visible string translated and the script renders and edits correctly; partial; menus only; none. Hours are to full, Opus 5.5 agent wall-clock, excluding the shared items below.

Language Code UI strings translated Dialogs / tooltips / help Script support Native review Status Hours to full
English en source (100%) ✅ Latin ✅ yes full 0
Simplified Chinese (Mandarin) zh-hans 929 entries; 98% of extracted, ~95% of visible most; newer panes English CJK ✅, IME ✅; Windows UI font fixed (#248); interface font chain covers every catalog character, installed CJK font after the embedded ones when it doesn't, PingFang found on macOS 12 (#486); no vertical text no partial 3–5
Spanish es ~930; 98% / ~95% most Latin ✅ no partial 1–2
Hindi hi 0 ❌ Devanagari shaping via HarfRust, untested; no hyphenation no none 4–6
Arabic ar 0 ❌ shaping, joining, lam-alef, bidi ✅ (#207); no kashida; no mirrored UI no none 6–8
French fr 0 ❌ Latin ✅ no none 3–4
Portuguese pt-br (pt-PT none) ~930; 98% / ~95% (pt-BR) most Latin ✅ no partial 2–4 (pt-BR finish + pt-PT)
Indonesian id 0 ❌ Latin ✅ no none 3–4
Japanese ja ~930; 98% / ~95% most CJK ✅, IME ✅; no vertical text, ruby or document grid no partial 3–5
German de 0 (PR #203 open) ❌ Latin ✅ no none 1–2
Korean ko 0 ❌ Hangul ✅; macOS Korean IME fixes pending (#163, #164) no none 3–5
Vietnamese vi 0 ❌ Latin with stacked diacritics, untested no none 3–4

Other shipped languages: 7 — Traditional Chinese (zh-hant), Ukrainian (uk), Serbian Cyrillic and Latin (sr, sr-latn, #250), Estonian (et), Turkish (tr) and Russian (ru), all partial. Estonian uses the existing fonts, follows et-EE system locales, and is available in Options or through ui.language with {"value":"et"}. Its 1,307 entries cover the existing interface catalog. Estonian spelling, grammar, dates and document templates are not added by the interface catalog. Turkish works the same way (tr-TR and tr-CY system locales, {"value":"tr"}) with all 1,307 entries. Command search folds the Turkish dotted and dotless I (italik finds İtalik, YAZI TİPİ finds Yazı Tipi) while English labels and ASCII command ids keep their usual matching. Turkish proofing is not included; terminology and checks: localization-tr.md.

Shared work (not in the per-language hours)

Item Hours Notes
Wrap the remaining English literals in tl! and translate them in every catalog 4–6 Makes the six partial languages full except script items
Mirrored (right-to-left) interface for Arabic and Hebrew 15–25 Ribbon, panes, dialogs, rulers
Vertical text, ruby, document grid (Chinese, Japanese, Korean) counted in layout-parity.md
Proofing dictionaries, grammar and hyphenation for the 11 non-English key languages 25–45 Open dictionaries only (licence check per dictionary); issues #25, #40, #100
Native-speaker review of every catalog human None reviewed yet

Revision history

Date Change Summary
2026-10-11 minor Chinese/Japanese interface fonts: a test checks every catalog character has a glyph; an installed CJK font follows the embedded faces whenever they miss one; macOS font asset folders searched for PingFang (#486)
2026-10-10 minor Russian interface (#300; 1,524 entries, built-in style names shown translated; covers everything the interface audit finds)
2026-10-11 minor Turkish interface catalog (1,307 entries), locale selection, saved preference, Turkish casing in command search and font coverage checks; catalog sizes re-counted
2026-10-11 trivial English spelling (#520): our supplement assets/spelling/en-extra.txt adds ~220 common modern words the Moby list lacks ("desktop", "download", "email"…)
2026-10-10 minor Estonian interface catalog, locale selection, saved preference and font coverage checks
2026-10-10 minor Serbian (Cyrillic and Latin) interface merged (#250)
2026-10-10 major First version: twelve-language table, catalog coverage measured, Word's 30 UI languages and 120 proofing tools listed