photocraft/docs/scorecard.md

PhotoCraft scorecard

Generated by cargo xtask scorecard from perf/budgets.toml, perf/baseline.json, crates/io/tests/corpus.rs, scorecard/*.toml and the source tree. Do not edit by hand: change the sources and regenerate (CI runs cargo xtask scorecard --check). Checklist statuses are verified against the code; numbers here supersede estimates elsewhere.

Summary

Area	Done	Partial	Missing	Key numbers
Performance	3	22	13	47 scenarios: 3 within budget, 22 over budget or failing, 15 tracked only, 6 not run, 7 not measurable yet (baseline 2026-10-05)
File compatibility	2	9	16	io corpus: oracle ≥ 146/170, round trip ≥ 169/170; psd-tools corpus: oracle ≥ 229/309, round trip ≥ 307/309; photoshop oracles: oracle ≥ 132/256, round trip ≥ 258/256
Tools	6	14	10
Workspace and UI	0	5	18	settings that do nothing: 57 of 135 (target 0)
Type	0	3	6
Automation	3	2	6	626 of 626 menu items live (100.0%)
Reliability	4	1	2	never-crash lints on 27 of 27 crates; panic_hunt present
Distribution	4	4	3
Open bugs	12	4	16

Performance

Budgets: perf/budgets.toml (targets from #209, #210, #211). Numbers: the committed baseline (perf/baseline.json, full run), updated only by cargo xtask perf --update-baseline. The nightly perf-nightly workflow runs cargo xtask perf on a fixed macOS runner and fails on a broken enforced budget or a p50 regression over 15 % against a baseline from the same machine class. "Over budget" rows are targets the code doesn't meet yet: they are reported, and only their regressions fail.

Baseline: 2026-10-05, commit f5d2bcb54a, Apple M4 Pro (48 GB), GPU Apple M4 Pro, macOS 15.6; load average 224.90 / 226.31 / 196.03 (1/5/15 min) at the start of the run.

Id	Scenario	Target	p50 ms	p95 ms	max ms	Peak RSS	GPU	Status	Issue
P1	Move a layer with layer styles (per drag update)	≤ 25 ms p95	321	535	535	825 MB	409 MB	over budget (target not met yet)	#209
P2	Change layer opacity	≤ 20 ms p95	276	443	443	639 MB	409 MB	over budget (target not met yet)	#209
P3	Change layer fill	≤ 20 ms p95	279	467	467	506 MB	409 MB	over budget (target not met yet)	#209
P4	Change blend mode	≤ 20 ms p95	206	423	423	579 MB	409 MB	over budget (target not met yet)	#209
P5	Toggle visibility	≤ 10 ms p95	178	425	425	668 MB	409 MB	over budget (target not met yet)	#209
P6	Undo a move	≤ 25 ms p95	256	530	530	650 MB	409 MB	over budget (target not met yet)	#209
P7	Redo a property change	≤ 25 ms p95	144	212	212	669 MB	409 MB	over budget (target not met yet)	#209
P8	Duplicate a 12 MP layer (first)	≤ 100 ms p95	508	699	699	907 MB	919 MB	over budget (target not met yet)	#209
P9	Duplicate a 12 MP layer (repeat)	≤ 20 ms p95	406	627	627	749 MB	919 MB	over budget (target not met yet)	#209
P10	Paste a 12 MP layer (first)	≤ 100 ms p95	1232	3136	3136	1.3 GB	1.4 GB	over budget (target not met yet)	#209
P11	Paste a 12 MP layer (repeat)	≤ 20 ms p95	445	1174	1174	958 MB	1.4 GB	over budget (target not met yet)	#209
P12	Arrow-key nudge in a 150-layer document	≤ 30 ms p95	–	–	–	–	–	missing: panicked: wgpu error: Validation Error / Caused by: / In Queue::write_buffer / Buffer with 'pc_compose_uniforms' label is invalid	#209
P13	Brush dab on a 15000×10000 16-bit document	≤ 80 ms p95	6.42	146	146	839 MB	2.0 GB	over budget (target not met yet)	#209
P14	Move a layer on a 15000×10000 16-bit document	≤ 80 ms p95	2698	4318	4318	1.5 GB	2.0 GB	over budget (target not met yet)	#209
P16	Brush dab on a 32-bit document with 20 layers	≤ 100 ms p95	21.5	161	161	793 MB	1.6 GB	over budget (target not met yet)	#209
P17	Move a layer on a 32-bit document with 20 layers	≤ 100 ms p95	386	681	681	1.2 GB	1.6 GB	over budget (target not met yet)	#209
P18	Open a 20 MP layered PSD: first pixels (today: fully opened)	≤ 1000 ms p95	1753	2794	2794	2.2 GB	1.9 GB	over budget (target not met yet)	#210
P19	Open a 20 MP layered PSD: editable	≤ 3000 ms p95	1753	2794	2794	2.2 GB	1.9 GB	pass	#210
P21	Content-Aware Fill on 10 MP	≤ 1500 ms p95	218	256	256	1.8 GB	1.8 GB	pass	#210
P22	Spot Healing stroke on 10 MP	≤ 500 ms p95	157	247	247	1.8 GB	1.9 GB	pass	#210
P24	Import 500 brushes (longest UI-thread step)	≤ 100 ms max	–	–	–	–	–	not run	#210
P25	Cancel a Gaussian Blur job on 24 MP (until the worker exits)	≤ 200 ms max	–	–	–	–	–	not run	#210
P49	Cancel a Content-Aware Fill job on 24 MP (until the worker exits)	≤ 200 ms max	–	–	–	–	–	not run	#210
P50	App frame time while a 24 MP Gaussian Blur job runs	≤ 16 ms p95	–	–	–	–	–	not run	#210
P26	Select › Modify › Smooth on 24 MP (radius 50)	≤ 100 ms p95	99.9	216	251	1.0 GB	–	over budget (target not met yet)	#211
P27	Select › Modify › Feather on 24 MP (radius 50)	≤ 100 ms p95	122	357	360	1.1 GB	–	over budget (target not met yet)	#211
P28	Content-Aware Scale 24 MP (to 90 % width)	≤ 3000 ms p95	954192	954192	954192	2.1 GB	–	over budget (target not met yet)	#211
P29	Select Subject on 24 MP, repeated	≤ 100 ms p95	559	693	693	1.4 GB	–	over budget (target not met yet)	#211
P31	Camera Raw exposure change (proxy)	≤ 10 ms	–	–	–	–	–	not run	#211
P33	Brush dab on A4 300 ppi CMYK (dab to screen)	≤ 6 ms p95	34.7	235	235	775 MB	87 MB	over budget (target not met yet)	#211
P36	Camera Raw exposure change with all SDR scopes (CPU)	≤ 10 ms p95	–	–	–	–	–	not run	#211
P40	Brush dab 60 px on 36 MP	track only	1.45	3.19	3.19	1.3 GB	–	tracked
P41	Gaussian Blur r 40 on 36 MP	track only	2963	3069	3069	1.9 GB	–	tracked
P42	Curves dialog change, layer preview, 36 MP	track only	38.7	158	158	1.1 GB	–	tracked
P43	Save .psd, 36 MP, 3 layers	track only	3047	3446	3446	1.2 GB	–	tracked
P44	Open .psd, 36 MP, 3 layers	track only	3535	4547	4547	1.6 GB	–	tracked
P45	Full refresh with layer effects, warm caches, 36 MP (GPU)	track only	105	160	160	714 MB	–	tracked
P46	Brush dab on a layer with effects, 36 MP (GPU)	track only	30.6	83.3	83.3	863 MB	–	tracked
P47	Font-size drag step, 50 type layers	track only	23.3	60.5	71.2	600 MB	–	tracked
P48	Full refresh of a 14000×14000 document	track only	8715	9897	9897	–	–	tracked

Not measurable yet (the code can't do it yet; no number is recorded):

Id	Scenario	Target	Why	Issue
P15	Zoom / pan frame time on a 15000×10000 16-bit document	≤ 16 ms per frame	no headless canvas frame harness yet (zoom and pan sample the GPU texture in the egui paint callback)	#209
P20	Open a 2 GB PSD / 4–5 GB PSB	opens with progress, editable, never blank	opens run in the background with progress (#210), but there are no generated large-file fixtures yet (#216)	#210
P23	Warp / Puppet / Perspective preview at 4K	≤ 16 ms per frame, commit in the background	the previews run inside the UI tools; no headless frame harness, no background commit	#210
P30	Liquify 800 px brush on 3500×2200 at full resolution	≤ 1 ms per update	the Liquify proxy is capped at 1600 px and the stroke path lives in the UI tool	#211
P32	Brush release on a long stroke	no hitch at mouse-up	the live renderer and the release re-render are UI-side; needs a frame harness	#211
P34	Brush preview memory, small dab on an 8K viewport	≤ 2 MiB	the live brush preview buffers are UI-side; no headless counter yet	#211
P35	Marquee drag on 24 MP with Alt/Shift	≤ 17 ms p95	Shift/Alt marquee modifiers don't exist yet (#208) and the drag preview is UI-side	#211

File compatibility

Corpus floors (crates/io/tests/corpus.rs): the enforced minimums; the corpus tests (cargo feature corpus, cargo xtask test-corpus, always run in CI) fail below them.

Corpus	Directory	Files	Oracle pass floor	Round-trip floor
io corpus	corpus/psd	170	146	169
psd-tools corpus	corpus/psd-tools	309	229	307
photoshop oracles	corpus/photoshop	256	132	258

Id	Target	Status	Issue	Note
FILE-215-1	Smart Objects export as embedded Smart Objects (SoLd + lnk2), not flat pixels	done	#215	psd_export.rs smart_blocks: PlLd + SoLd, source in lnk2 (.pcraft -> PSB); engine tests/smart_psd.rs; Photoshop 2026 opens 8/16-bit exports as live smart objects. Linked files are embedded
FILE-215-2	Smart Filters survive PSD save and re-open (filterFX descriptor read and written)	partial	#215	smart_map.rs: 14 filters plus a verified Camera Raw subset mapped both ways, others kept verbatim, mask in FEid; io tests/smart_corpus.rs. PhotoCraft-only filters (Twirl, Liquify…) and unmapped Camera Raw settings are left out of filterFX with a warning
FILE-215-3	Filter mask can be painted directly, with undo	missing	#215	smart_cmds.rs:382 mask only from the selection
FILE-215-4	Adjustments (Hue/Sat + Colorize, Curves, Levels, Shadows/Highlights) apply as Smart Filters	partial	#215	PSD Levels/Curves/Shadows-Highlights smart filters render (adjust_cmds.rs adjust_as_filter); Image › Adjustments on a smart object doesn't add one yet
FILE-215-5	Smart Filter rows: collapse, mask thumb, blend icon, drag reorder, context menu, live preview	partial	#215	smart_ui.rs:31 rows + visibility + editor; no collapse, drag or context menu
FILE-215-6	Smart Object corner skew and perspective (quad or homography transform)	missing	#215	doc lib.rs:312 SmartObject.transform is an Affine
FILE-215-7	Layered TIFF read and write (tag 37724), honouring the ask-before-saving pref	done	#215	psd tiff.rs (ImageSourceData, both byte orders), io tiff_layers.rs, ui tiff_options_ui.rs (Discard Layers and Save a Copy); extra alpha channels are not written (one transparency sample)
FILE-215-8	Large and BigTIFF import with banded decode across all IFDs	missing	#215	codecs tiff.rs:3 'Only the first IFD is read'
FILE-215-9	SVG opens and places as shape layers or a vector Smart Object	missing	#215	No SVG codec or import
FILE-215-10	Multi-page PDF save, PDF presentation, layer comps to PDF, vector/text output, PDF import	missing	#215	Only print_cmds.rs:133 print_pdf (raster print page)
FILE-215-11	RAW: lossy DNG, highlight modes, .xmp sidecars, RAW prefs wired, per-camera corpus	missing	#215	raw sensor.rs:210 lossy DNG unsupported; raw_defaults unread; no xmp
FILE-215-12	Camera Raw dialog shows a histogram; settings persist as a PSD Smart Filter	partial	#215	Interactive RGB/Lab scopes. PSD WB/Light/Presence, curves, HSL, grading, sharpening/noise detail, grain and numeric vignette controls mapped with descriptor preservation. Active manual Optics and unverified vignette style keep the updated ACR 18.4 fixture opaque; PSD/.pcraft saves preserve it. HDR, remaining settings and Photoshop acceptance still open
FILE-215-13	Video layer frames persist in .pcraft; PSD video layers mapped	partial	#215	format convert.rs:89 + tests/roundtrip.rs:282 persist frames; no PSD video mapping
FILE-215-14	User swatch model with ACO/ASE import and export	missing	#215	panels.rs:954 const SWATCHES: [[u8; 3]; 40]
FILE-215-15	Layer Style contour picker, curve editor, presets, .shc import/export	missing	#215	doc effects.rs:57 Contour model only
FILE-215-16	Advanced Blending (knockout, blend as group, mask hides effects) end to end	missing	#215	No knockout / blend_interior / transparency_shapes in doc, compose or io
FILE-215-17	CMYK/RGB documents preview spot inks; spot plates export (TIFF extra samples, PDF)	missing	#215	compose multichannel.rs:1 spot preview for Multichannel only
FILE-215-18	Save for Web per-slice settings remembered; Export As remembers and offers nearest scaling	partial	#215	file_ui.rs:188 last_web in-session only; export_dialog.rs:16 fixed defaults
FILE-215-19	Save As JPEG opens a JPEG Options dialog (quality 0-12, format options)	missing	#215	ExportSettings has jpeg_quality 1-100 only (lib.rs:118)
FILE-215-20	Artboard tool with handles and + buttons, Duplicate Artboard beside, vector PDF pages	partial	#215	artboard_ui.rs:1 names/properties only; no tool, + buttons or duplicate
FILE-215-21	Local libraries of colours, patterns, images and layers, as linked items or copies	missing	#215	Only preset libraries (preset_store.rs)
FILE-216-1	Every corpus fetched and enforced in CI, cached by pin	missing	#216	No corpus step in ci.yml; in progress in #190
FILE-216-2	Large-file fixtures: 20 MP, 150-layer, generated 2 GB PSD and 4-5 GB PSB stress tests	partial	#216	4-5 GB PSB fixtures: psd example big_psb writes them (raw and RLE, planes past 2 GiB), io example big_psb_check opens and checks them; opt-in io tests/large_psb.rs (2.5 GB merged image). No 2 GB PSD, 150-layer or 20 MP fixture, nothing in CI
FILE-216-3	TIFF, RAW and EXR corpora read by tests; per-camera RAW coverage reported	missing	#216	corpus/tiff, raw and exr only listed by xtask corpus; no test reads them
FILE-216-4	Exports re-open in a third-party oracle editor	missing	#216	The round trip is our export -> our import
FILE-216-5	Save-path tests: layered TIFF, PDF, SVG, ACO/ASE, .shc, Smart Filters, atomic-save failure	missing	#216	Features absent; no atomic-save failure-injection test
FILE-216-6	30-50 end-to-end workflow acceptance tasks driven through MCP or commands	partial	#216	automation/tests/agent_tasks.rs: 10 MCP tasks

Tools

Id	Target	Status	Issue	Note
TOOL-213-1	Pencil tool: aliased 1 px painting, square pixel-aligned cursor	done	#213	Tool::Pencil (B group): live aliased strokes on the pixel grid, square cursor, Auto Erase; pencil_tests.rs
TOOL-213-2	Mixer Brush tool on the toolbar	done	#213	Tool::MixerBrush in the Brush (B) flyout; Wet/Load/Mix/Flow/Sample All Layers options, command/control dispatch and selection-clipping tests
TOOL-213-3	Patch tool with a live preview of the patched area	done	#213	paint.patch (retouch_cmds/patch.rs, source/destination) + Tool::Patch (J group: lasso, then drag the selection); the drag shows the heal live (patch_preview.rs, coarse colour fit: 1000x1000 in 52 ms)
TOOL-213-4	Content-Aware Move tool reusing inpaint completion	partial	#213	paint.contentAwareMove (retouch_cmds/content_aware_move.rs: move/extend, Structure 1-7, Color 0-10, Sample All Layers; background job) + Tool::ContentAwareMove (J group: lasso, then drag). Missing: Transform On Drop, a live preview of the result (the drag shows the outline only)
TOOL-213-5	Painting a type/shape/smart/fill layer offers to rasterize, then continues the stroke	done	#213	rasterize_prompt.rs: OK rasterizes then paints (two history states), Cancel does nothing; drivable via ui.dialog.confirm
TOOL-213-6	Fill dialog: contents, blend, opacity, preserve transparency; remembered; Shift+Backspace	done	#213	fill_ui.rs dialog over edit.fill (fill_cmds.rs): all contents, mode, opacity, preserve; remembered in prefs; Shift+F5 / Shift+Backspace
TOOL-213-7	Live stroke preview for every brush-based retouch tool	missing	#213	Live stroke only for Brush and Eraser (canvas.rs:1684)
TOOL-213-8	Clone Source: W/H link, drawn overlay (opacity/blend/clip/auto-hide), Alt target cursor	partial	#213	Panel W/H + overlay settings (preset_panels.rs:946-1015); no link, overlay never drawn
TOOL-213-9	Eyedropper comparison ring (new colour above, current below) while sampling	missing	#213	sample_eyedropper (canvas.rs:1552) draws no ring
TOOL-213-10	Ctrl+Alt drag resizes brush size/hardness with an on-canvas readout	missing	#213	Only [ ] resize (shortcuts.rs:270)
TOOL-213-11	Editable pressure curve, global and per control	missing	#213	No pressure curve in engine, paint or ui-egui
TOOL-213-12	Import an image file as a brush tip	missing	#213	Only brush.defineFromSelection and brush.presets.importAbr
TOOL-213-13	Brush regression tests: no seams, hard edge, zero-scatter defaults, ABR never black	partial	#213	Missing-pattern ABR test (abr_map/tests.rs:181), hardness test; no seam/black tests
TOOL-213-14	Tablet: no OS arrow cursor over the canvas on macOS, Windows and Linux	partial	#213	Brush tools set CursorIcon::None (canvas.rs:1259-1275); not verified per OS
TOOL-214-1	Select and Mask workspace: view modes, Refine Edge brush, 6 outputs	partial	#214	Opens the generic select.refineEdge dialog (menus.rs:308)
TOOL-214-2	Marquee: Shift square, Alt from centre, live W x H readout	partial	#214	marquee_end supports shift (chrome_ui.rs:167) but canvas.rs passes false (#208)
TOOL-214-3	Color Range test: Sampled Colors at Fuzziness 0 selects the exact match only	partial	#214	Fuzziness-0 tests cover midtones/shadows only (selection_cmds.rs:444-447)
TOOL-214-4	Move tool: box-select layers, Auto-Select hover outline, double-click fit, drag to a tab	missing	#214	move_mods.rs covers Shift/Alt/arrows only
TOOL-214-5	Right-click menu during Free Transform (scale, rotate, skew, warp, flip, rotate 90/180)	missing	#214	No context menu in canvas.rs or transform_tool.rs
TOOL-214-6	Puppet Warp mesh follows the object outline (constrained triangulation)	missing	#214	algo/puppet.rs:136 builds a block-grid mesh
TOOL-214-7	Content-Aware Scale through the Free Transform box with a live proxy preview	partial	#214	edit.contentAwareScale (edit_menu_cmds.rs:899) behind a parameter dialog
TOOL-214-8	A measured ruler angle prefills Image Rotation > Arbitrary (0.01 deg)	missing	#214	Arbitrary rotation is a generic dialog; ruler only feeds straighten
TOOL-214-9	Crop: W x H x Resolution with units, saved crop presets, Straighten in the options bar	partial	#214	Ratio dropdown and fields only (panels.rs:551-579)
TOOL-214-10	Pen: Alt breaks a handle, Shift 45 deg, Ctrl direct-selects, Backspace, close-drag handle	missing	#214	pen_down gets no modifiers (canvas.rs:1632)
TOOL-214-11	Stroke Path dialog: pick any brush-based tool, Simulate Pressure	partial	#214	path.stroke brush, pencil, eraser (vector_cmds.rs:1170); brush-only button, no dialog
TOOL-214-12	Shapes: on-canvas corner radius handles, shape feather, selection to shape with tolerance	partial	#214	select.convertToShape with tolerance (vector_cmds.rs:1256); radius as a field only
TOOL-214-13	Mask Properties: Density and Feather controls	partial	#214	Vector-mask density/feather in the engine (vector_cmds.rs:948); no UI controls
TOOL-214-14	Vanishing Point window: draw and edit planes, paste, clone in perspective	partial	#214	filter.vanishingPoint (vp_cmds.rs:15) behind a parameter dialog
TOOL-214-15	Content-Aware Fill workspace: paint the sampling area, preview, rotate/scale/mirror, new layer	partial	#214	Engine sampling auto, rect, custom (edit_menu_cmds.rs:324); generic dialog
TOOL-214-16	Liquify: redo (Cmd+Shift+Z)	done	#214	liquify_ui.rs supports bounded redo through Cmd+Shift+Z and the control channel; new strokes clear redo

Workspace and UI

Settings that do nothing: 57 of 135 (target 0, #204). Counted by the prefs audit (xtask/src/scorecard.rs): a Preferences field counts as read when code outside the prefs model (prefs.rs except its impl Session blocks; tests excluded; the schema-driven dialog never names a field) accesses section.field, or .section and .field in the same file, or calls a section method that reads self.field. It is a heuristic lower bound: a generic name can look read when it isn't.

Unread: general.color_picker, general.beep_when_done, general.export_clipboard, general.resize_image_during_place, general.always_create_smart_objects_when_placing, general.animated_zoom, general.zoom_resizes_windows, interface.show_channels_in_color, interface.dynamic_color_sliders, workspace.auto_collapse_icon_panels, workspace.auto_show_hidden_panels, workspace.open_documents_as_tabs, workspace.enable_floating_document_window_docking, workspace.large_tabs, workspace.enable_narrow_options_bar, tools.zoom_clicked_point_to_center, tools.enable_flick_panning, tools.vary_round_brush_hardness_on_hud, tools.show_transformation_values, tools.double_click_layer_mask_launches_select_and_mask, file_handling.image_previews, file_handling.lowercase_extension, file_handling.save_in_background, file_handling.ignore_exif_profile_tag, file_handling.maximize_psd_compatibility, performance.cache_levels, performance.legacy_compositing, scratch_disks.disks, cursors.brush_preview_color, units_and_rulers.type_units, units_and_rulers.column_width, units_and_rulers.gutter, units_and_rulers.print_resolution, units_and_rulers.screen_resolution, plug_ins.show_extension_panels, plug_ins.allow_scripts_to_connect, plug_ins.generator_enabled, type_.smart_quotes, type_.missing_glyph_protection, type_.show_font_names_in_english, type_.use_esc_to_commit, type_.text_engine, type_.font_preview, type_.fill_new_type_layers_with_placeholder, type_.recent_fonts, enhanced_controls.scrubby_slider_acceleration, enhanced_controls.touch_gestures, enhanced_controls.zoom_with_trackpad_pinch, enhanced_controls.rotate_view_with_trackpad, raw_defaults.color_space, raw_defaults.bit_depth, raw_defaults.resolution, raw_defaults.sharpen_for, raw_defaults.open_as_smart_object, raw_defaults.apply_auto_tone, integrations.allow_agent_control, integrations.control_port.

Id	Target	Status	Issue	Note
UI-217-1	Tool options, last Export As / Save for Web / Fill settings and font recents persist	partial	#217	Fill (fill_ui.rs:72) and Liquify (liquify_ui.rs:64, #418) keep their settings in Preferences (prefs.dialogs); no tool_options/export fields in Preferences; export_dialog.rs:21 png/85
UI-217-2	Window size and dock width remembered across restarts	missing	#217	main.rs:46 native_options(): fixed 1440x900, centred on the main monitor (#419); dock.rs:529 snapshot omits the width
UI-217-3	File > Open starts in the last-used folder	missing	#217	services.rs:110 FileDialog::new() without set_directory
UI-217-4	Preferences all take effect; recent files persist and honour recent_file_count (#204)	missing	#217	See the prefs audit and BUG-204-*
UI-217-5	Panel groups can float (menu + drag out of the dock) and are restored at launch	missing	#217	No floating groups in dock.rs/panels.rs
UI-217-6	Document tabs: overflow list, context menu (Close/Others/All/Reveal), drag to reorder	partial	#217	canvas.rs: Close/Others/All context menu with unsaved prompt; overflow, Reveal, drag reorder still missing
UI-217-7	Command palette shows recently run commands on an empty query	missing	#217	palette.rs:83-108 fuzzy hits only
UI-217-8	Tool-specific canvas right-click menu; right-click spelling suggestions in text fields	partial	#217	paint_mouse.rs brush picker and canvas_tool_menu.rs selection actions; other tools and text spelling menus missing
UI-217-9	UI scale presets 100/115/125/150/200 % through zoom_factor, remembered	missing	#217	prefs.rs:61 UiScale unused; input_tests.rs:71 asserts zoom_factor stays 1.0
UI-217-10	Appearance: animation toggle, canvas pattern toggle per theme, start-screen recents	missing	#217	No such prefs; start screen (canvas.rs:825) has no recents
UI-217-11	Soft dark and soft light themes with picker previews; outlined knobs in light themes	missing	#217	theme.rs:28 five themes
UI-217-12	Save custom New Document presets; a real Recent category	missing	#217	new_doc_ui.rs:17 'Recent' is a static list
UI-217-13	Numeric fields accept arithmetic and units; scrubby labels; double-click resets a slider	partial	#217	widgets.rs:132 DragValue scrubs and takes + - * / arithmetic; no units in expressions, label scrub or reset
UI-217-14	Layers panel: wheel steps blend modes, drop on New/Trash duplicates/deletes, checker behind art	missing	#217	panels.rs:1108 plain dropdown; trash is click-only (panels.rs:1213)
UI-217-15	Curves: smoothing / pencil mode, black/grey/white eyedroppers, tooltips	missing	#217	adjust_editors.rs:397 has none of them
UI-217-16	Hue/Saturation: Saturation and Lightness sliders get hue-following colour tracks	missing	#217	Only the Hue slider has a gradient
UI-217-17	Color panel: wheel plus RGB/HSB/CMYK/Lab/Gray/Web slider modes; resizes with its group	missing	#217	panels.rs:1837 single field + hex/RGB readout
UI-217-18	Alt+wheel zooms in gentle ~5 % steps; zoom controls uncramped	missing	#217	canvas.rs:1107-1125 no Alt handling
UI-217-19	Shortcut hints rendered per platform; Reveal label per OS	missing	#217	~33 hard-coded modifier glyph strings in ui-egui; menu_catalog.rs:341 one label
UI-217-20	'Show rulers in new documents' preference; guides stored as f64	missing	#217	No rulers pref; doc lib.rs:523 guides are Vec
UI-217-21	One Preset Manager for every preset kind with folders, search, reorder, load/save sets	partial	#217	edit_menu_cmds.rs:714 covers brushes, custom shapes, patterns with reorder
UI-217-22	Stamp Visible into a new layer keeping originals; Alt+Merge keeps originals	missing	#217	Only layer.mergeVisible (edit_cmds.rs:416)
UI-217-23	Layer clipboard: copy/paste whole layers (masks, styles, type) between documents	missing	#217	Only copy/paste layer style (extra_cmds.rs:592)

Type

Id	Target	Status	Issue	Note
TYPE-218-1	Type on a path: path shape, glyphs along the curve, caret follows, PSD round trip	missing	#218	doc text.rs:209 TextShape has Point and Box only
TYPE-218-2	Paragraph direction (Auto/LTR/RTL) in the panel and options bar; visual RTL caret	missing	#218	Engine has TextDirection (text.rs:155); no UI
TYPE-218-3	Thai/Khmer/Indic fallback fonts; golden shaping tests for complex scripts and RTL	missing	#218	fonts.rs:28 fallback covers Arabic/Hebrew; no per-script golden tests (only a bidi test)
TYPE-218-4	Variable font axis sliders from the font's axes; opsz follows the point size	partial	#218	type_cmds.rs:184 accepts variations; FaceInfo.axes unused in the UI
TYPE-218-5	OpenType UI: Character panel buttons, Numerals and Stylistic Sets submenus	partial	#218	Type > OpenType toggles (type_extra_cmds.rs:512); no panel buttons or submenus
TYPE-218-6	Manual pair kerning (Alt+arrows), optical kerning rendered, both round-trip PSD (#206)	missing	#218	Optical renders as Metrics (text.rs:21); Alt+arrow moves by word
TYPE-218-7	Warp Text dialog previews live and opens with the layer's current warp	missing	#218	view_cmds.rs:834 always seeds arc, bend 50
TYPE-218-8	Text editing: select all, double/triple/quadruple-click selection, paste, with tests	partial	#218	Cmd+A, paste and double-click exist; no triple/quadruple click, no tests
TYPE-218-9	Offer 'Rasterize and continue?' for Distort/Perspective/Warp on live type	missing	#218	No such prompt

Automation

Menu wiring (docs/parity.md): 626 of 626 menu items live (100.0%). This counts dispatch, not behaviour.

Id	Target	Status	Issue	Note
AUTO-1	Every menu item dispatches a command id (UI, CLI, control channel and MCP share them)	done		docs/parity.md: all menu items live; menus.rs is_live
AUTO-219-1	Record actions in a document-independent form (implicit layer, merged type keystrokes)	missing	#219	actions.rs:47 copies raw journal entries with explicit layer ids
AUTO-219-2	Actions panel: step and dialog toggles, reorder, delete a step, Stop, sets, .atn import	missing	#219	Panel deletes whole actions only (actions.rs:146)
AUTO-219-3	actions.record/stop/play/list commands for agents and the CLI	done	#219	actions.list/get/record/stop/play/delete in actions_cmds.rs; the panel, CLI and MCP share them. Nested steps pass the session authorize hook.
AUTO-219-4	Replay tests for crop, filters, selections and styled text on a second document	missing	#219	One replay test (actions.rs:171: new layer, rect select, fill)
AUTO-219-5	Batch: subfolders, open documents, naming template, progress/cancel, error log, stop	partial	#219	file_cmds.rs:590-631 folder/array input, per-file errors; no recursion, template or cancel
AUTO-219-6	Plug-in ABI v2: panel kind, progress/cancel calls, read other layers, Last Filter repeats	missing	#219	runtime.rs:15 ABI_VERSION = 1; manifest.rs:18 Kind::Filter only
AUTO-219-7	Local ONNX models behind a flag, managed in Preferences; subject select, background removal	missing	#219	No ONNX runtime dependency
AUTO-219-8	xtask check that every panel button routes through a command id	missing	#219	No such xtask check
AUTO-219-9	Headless commands for in-canvas type editing, Liquify/Puppet strokes, transform handles	done	#219	type.hitTest, type.caret, type.navigate; filter.liquify strokes, edit.puppetWarp pins, type.edit, edit.transform
AUTO-219-10	Agent acceptance suite grown to 30-50 workflows	partial	#219	automation/tests/agent_tasks.rs runs 10 workflows over MCP

Reliability

Never-crash attribute on 27 of 27 crate roots.

Id	Target	Status	Issue	Note
REL-1	panic_hunt fuzzes every command with adversarial params	done		engine/tests/panic_hunt.rs: every command, own thread, 4 s timeout; #[ignore], run in the gate
REL-2	Every workspace crate carries the never-crash deny(clippy::unwrap_used, ...) attribute	done		Counted automatically above (crate roots under crates/ and apps/); testkit gained it in #221
REL-3	The app catches escaped panics around command dispatch and import/export	partial		engine lib.rs:336 dispatch; crash_guard.rs:21 import/export; the dispatch guard is untested
REL-4	Atomic save (temp, fsync, rename) for every document write	done	#203	photocraft_format::atomic_write (format/src/atomic.rs, #230): same-dir temp, sync_all, rename with Windows PermissionDenied retry, Unix dir fsync; every document write site routes through it and format/src/atomic/tests.rs failure-injects write, rename and read-only-dir errors
REL-212-1	Fallible allocation for paste/erase/fill/transform/save/import, clear out-of-memory error	missing	#212	try_reserve only in io/flat.rs:221; codec max_alloc limits cover decode only
REL-212-2	Export switches to PSB when the estimated file size exceeds 2 GB	done	#212	PSD export uses checked size estimates for raster, masks, channels, and retained metadata
REL-212-3	Tests: an allocation-limit injection makes each command Err with the document unchanged	missing	#212	Only codec/raw max_alloc tests (codecs/tests/limits.rs:48)

Distribution

Id	Target	Status	Issue	Note
DIST-1	macOS universal build (aarch64 + x86_64), signed and notarized	done		release.yml:66,75,93 (macos-15); 0.2.0 shipped notarized
DIST-2	Windows x64 and x86 builds	partial		release.yml:113-114; signing skipped with a warning until the signing material exists
DIST-3	Linux x86_64 and aarch64: AppImage, deb, rpm, tar.gz	done		release.yml:162-163,186
DIST-4	Flatpak single-file bundles, x86_64 and aarch64	done		release.yml:204-216 (#163)
DIST-5	Web build (wasm32, trunk)	done		release.yml:312
DIST-6	FreeBSD 14 x86_64 tar.gz (/usr/local tree) built in a FreeBSD VM	partial		release.yml:242-283 (freebsd job) + packaging/freebsd/package.sh; layout checked with --dry-run, not yet produced by a release run
DIST-220-1	Help > Check for Updates plus an opt-out periodic release-feed check on all desktops	missing	#220	No update check in crates
DIST-220-2	Windows ARM64 (aarch64-pc-windows-msvc) in the release matrix, signed like x64	missing	#220	release.yml:113-114 only x86_64 and i686 msvc
DIST-220-3	In-app bug report with reviewable diagnostics that opens a prefilled issue	missing	#220	No bug report dialog in crates
DIST-220-4	Translation coverage per language reported by xtask; RTL layout for Arabic and Hebrew	partial	#220	cargo xtask i18n-coverage reports per-language coverage (#427); no RTL layout yet
DIST-220-5	Linux AppImage x86_64 + aarch64 ship; Flatpak kept; Flathub later (#173)	partial	#220	AppImage and Flatpak ship (release.yml:162-216); Flathub not done

Open bugs

Id	Target	Status	Issue	Note
BUG-203-1	Every document write goes through one atomic_write (temp, fsync, rename)	done	#203	photocraft_format::atomic_write (format/src/atomic.rs, #230/8227071); every write site routes through it: engine file_cmds.rs write_file and preset_store.rs, automation files.rs/headless.rs/workspace.rs, app services.rs write_atomic, format store.rs and autosave.rs
BUG-203-2	Temp file in the same dir, sync_all, rename over target, fsync dir on Unix	done	#203	atomic.rs: temp_name in the same dir, create_new + write_all + sync_all, Unix directory fsync after the rename
BUG-203-3	Windows: retry the rename with backoff on PermissionDenied	done	#203	atomic.rs RenameRetry::platform(): seven retries from 10 ms on Windows; retry_rename is shared with automation's cap-std workspace write
BUG-203-4	Unwritable directory errors clearly, never falls back to writing in place	done	#203	atomic.rs maps read-only dir, disk-full and cross-device rename errors to messages that say the original was not changed; there is no in-place fallback path
BUG-203-5	On any failure the original file is untouched and the temp file removed	done	#203	atomic.rs removes the temp file on every failure; tests assert the original bytes survive write and rename failures
BUG-203-6	Failure-injection tests: mid-write, rename and read-only dir errors keep original bytes	done	#203	format/src/atomic/tests.rs: Faulty AtomicFs injects mid-write StorageFull, rename failure and a read-only dir; locked-target retries, symlink and file-mode preservation covered too
BUG-204-1	Interface prefs (UI scale, font size, channels in colour, sliders, tooltips) wired or hidden	missing	#204	prefs.rs:196-202; no reader outside prefs.rs (see the prefs audit)
BUG-204-2	workspace.large_tabs, animated_zoom, auto_show_home_screen wired or hidden	missing	#204	prefs.rs:163,166,229; no reader outside prefs.rs
BUG-204-3	RAW prefs and ask_before_saving_layered_tiff read, or hidden	partial	#204	ask_before_saving_layered_tiff drives the TIFF Options prompt (ui-egui tiff_options_ui.rs); raw_defaults (prefs.rs:712) still has no readers
BUG-204-4	Recent files persisted through prefs across restarts	done	#204	crates/ui-egui/src/lib.rs::push_recent stores the list in preferences; prefs_ui::load restores it and recent_files_survive_a_restart_and_honour_the_count verifies reload
BUG-204-5	Recent-files list honours recent_file_count (default 20)	done	#204	lib.rs push_recent caps the list with recent_cap (recent_file_count); menus.rs covers default and custom limits
BUG-204-6	Test: every Prefs field is read somewhere or on a hidden allowlist	partial	#204	The scorecard's prefs audit counts unread fields; no engine test or allowlist yet
BUG-205-1	Free Transform with a selection moves only the selected part of a linked mask	missing	#205	transform_cmds.rs:127-130 warps the whole linked mask even when the selection split pixels
BUG-205-2	Live transform preview draws the layer with its mask applied	missing	#205	transform_tool.rs:173 preview_image uses the raw surface
BUG-205-3	edit.transform honours target mask: transforms only a targeted, unlinked mask	missing	#205	transform_cmds.rs:214-270 never reads a target param
BUG-205-4	Test: a linked raster mask with no selection moves with the pixels	partial	#205	Implemented at transform_cmds.rs:127; no raster-mask test
BUG-205-5	Tests: linked mask + selection stays aligned; unlinked stays; targeted mask only	missing	#205	Unlinked case honoured (m.linked check, l.128) but untested; the other two not implemented
BUG-206-1	CharStyle models per-character manual kerning separately from the auto-kern mode	missing	#206	doc/text.rs:76 only kerning: Kerning enum (Metrics/Optical/Off)
BUG-206-2	PSD import keeps Optical and manual Kerning values	missing	#206	text/psd.rs:264 maps anything not Off to Metrics; Kerning value ignored
BUG-206-3	PSD export writes the real AutoKerning mode and Kerning values	missing	#206	text/psd.rs:380-381 AutoKerning bool only; Kerning hard-coded 0
BUG-206-4	Alt+Left/Right at a collapsed caret adjusts pair kerning; Character panel field	missing	#206	type_tool.rs:896-912 only a mode combo
BUG-206-5	Tests: PSD round trip of manual and Optical kerning, a real file in the oracle corpus	missing	#206	No kerning round-trip test
BUG-207-1	Retouch tools respect the paint target (mask, alpha channel, Quick Mask)	missing	#207	retouch_cmds.rs:83 run_stroke always uses l.surface_mut(); no paint_target() call
BUG-207-2	Sample All Layers applies to Blur, Sharpen and Smudge	missing	#207	Checkbox at retouch_ui.rs:171-190 is not passed to the stroke commands
BUG-207-3	Smudge mixes premultiplied RGBA (no dark fringe at transparent edges)	missing	#207	No premultiply in paint/src/retouch.rs
BUG-207-4	edit.transform transforms a targeted alpha channel	missing	#207	transform_cmds.rs transform() has no target handling
BUG-207-5	Tests: per-tool mask/channel targeting, Sample All Layers, no smudge fringe	missing	#207	Only smudge_drags_colour_along_the_stroke (retouch.rs:407)
BUG-208-1	Shift while dragging a Rect/Elliptical Marquee constrains to a square/circle	done	#208	canvas.rs marquee_corners applies Shift via Drag::marquee_mods; marquee_tests.rs::shift_during_the_drag_draws_a_square_and_the_readout_follows covers the drag
BUG-208-2	Alt while dragging a marquee draws from the centre	done	#208	canvas.rs marquee_corners centres Alt drags; marquee_tests.rs::alt_draws_from_the_centre_and_shift_alt_a_centred_circle verifies rectangles and ellipses
BUG-208-3	W x H px readout beside the cursor while dragging a marquee	done	#208	canvas.rs marquee_readout draws the readout; marquee_tests.rs asserts dimensions while dragging and its removal after release
BUG-208-4	Add/subtract/intersect from modifiers pressed before the drag, kept by a test	partial	#208	Mods captured at press (canvas.rs:1679, used :1779); only a badge test (tool_feedback.rs:195)
BUG-208-5	Kittest: Shift drag gives a square, Alt drag is centred, readout matches the size	done	#208	crates/ui-egui/src/marquee_tests.rs covers Shift, Alt, selection bounds, W/H readout and drag completion